Is It Cheaper to Sand Floors or Carpet?

Sand floors vs. Carpeting: Let’s Explore Which Offers the Best Value for Your Budget?

When it comes to home improvement, we’re always trying to get the most bang for our buck. One of the most common dilemmas people face is whether it’s cheaper to sand old wooden floors or lay down new carpeting. You’re not just deciding on aesthetics—you’re also weighing long-term value, comfort, and, of course, cost.

But here’s the thing: it’s not always as straightforward as it seems. What might seem like a quick, affordable fix could end up costing more in the long run, while a more expensive option upfront could save you a small fortune over time. The decision between floor sanding and carpeting isn’t just about today’s price tag; it’s about factoring in future maintenance, durability, and how well your choice fits with your home’s style and function. So, before you roll out the carpet or dust off that sander, let’s take a closer look at what’s really involved.

Let’s break it down and answer the all-important question: Is it cheaper to sand floors or carpet?

1. The Case for Sanding Wooden Floors

If you’ve got wooden floors hidden under years of grime, you might be tempted to reveal and restore them to their former glory. Sanding and refinishing could give your home a fresh, timeless look. But what’s the damage to your wallet?

The Costs of Sanding

Sanding a wooden floor isn’t a straightforward job. It requires a fair bit of elbow grease, patience, and, unless you fancy yourself as the next Bob the Builder, professional help.

In the UK, the cost to sand and refinish hardwood floors ranges from £12 to £25 per square metre. Now, if you’re doing it yourself, hiring a sanding machine will set you back around £60 to £100 per day, depending on where you rent it from. Add in the cost of sandpaper, varnish, or stain, and you’re looking at an additional £50 to £100.

And don’t forget, this is dusty, messy work. If you’re living in the house while it’s happening, you’ll want to budget for a professional cleaning afterwards or at least stock up on cleaning supplies.

Maintenance and Durability

Once sanded and sealed, wooden floors can last for decades with minimal upkeep. Regular sweeping and the occasional mop will keep them looking sharp. Every ten years or so, they might need another light refinishing. Long-term? These floors are a solid investment.

2. The Case for Carpeting

Carpet, on the other hand, offers that instant cosy feel underfoot. It’s especially appealing in colder months when bare wood can be, well, chilly. But what about the numbers?

The Costs of Carpeting

Carpet costs vary wildly depending on the material, but let’s break it down. A decent mid-range carpet will cost around £10 to £30 per square metre. Underlay (which you’ll need for comfort and insulation) will add £3 to £10 per square metre.

And then there’s installation. A professional fitting can run you between £3 to £7 per square metre, depending on the complexity of the room. For a quick mental tally: for a 20 square metre room, carpeting could cost anywhere between £320 and £940, including installation.

Maintenance and Lifespan

Here’s where carpets start to fall short. Carpets, while cosy, aren’t exactly known for their longevity. Depending on traffic and wear, they might last anywhere from 5 to 15 years. You’ll also need to factor in regular cleaning—especially if you’ve got pets or kids. Stains, spills, and general wear and tear mean you’ll be paying for carpet cleaning services or buying a good steam cleaner sooner rather than later.

3. Longevity vs. Immediate Comfort

There’s an old saying: buy cheap, buy twice. And that’s something to think about when considering the lifespan of your flooring. Sanded wooden floors are, hands down, the more durable option. Wood floors can be refinished multiple times, lasting anywhere from 20 to 100 years. That’s serious staying power.

Carpets, on the other hand, are more disposable. Even the best carpets will eventually need replacing. So while the upfront cost might be lower, if you plan to stay in your home long-term, you’ll need to budget for replacements.

4. Aesthetic Appeal and Resale Value

It’s worth noting that wooden floors tend to be more universally appealing. They’re a popular selling point for potential buyers, adding an air of elegance and timelessness to any home. Carpets, however, can be a bit more subjective. One person’s soft beige dream is another’s dated nightmare.

In short, if you’re thinking of resale value, wooden floors typically offer more return on investment.

5. So, What’s Cheaper?

In the short term, carpeting is often the cheaper option. Even with installation costs, a new carpet is generally more affordable than sanding and refinishing floors. However, in the long term, sanded floors are the more economical choice. Their durability and minimal maintenance costs can save you money down the line.

6. When to Choose Sanding

• You have existing wooden floors in decent condition.
• You want a long-lasting, durable solution.
• You’re thinking about resale value and aesthetics.
• You’re prepared for the upfront cost and potential mess.

7. When to Choose Carpet

• You’re on a tight budget and need a quick, affordable solution.
• You want comfort and warmth underfoot, especially in bedrooms.
• You’re okay with replacing the carpet in 5 to 10 years.
• You don’t mind regular cleaning to maintain its appearance.

Final Thoughts

In the end, whether sanding your floors or laying down carpet is cheaper depends on your priorities and long-term plans. Carpeting is often the more affordable choice upfront, offering comfort and warmth at a lower initial cost. However, it comes with the trade-off of regular maintenance and replacement over time.

On the other hand, sanding and refinishing wooden floors may seem pricier at first, but it offers durability that can last for decades. With minimal upkeep and a timeless appeal, it could be the more cost-effective option in the long run, especially if you value longevity and increased home resale value.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to what suits your lifestyle and budget best. If you need a quick, budget-friendly solution, carpet might be your answer. But if you’re thinking about a long-term investment and classic style, sanding your floors could provide more value over time.